Identity and access management decisions are hard because the category mixes full IAM platforms, OIDC providers, access proxies, policy engines, password managers, and authenticator apps. The May 2026 ToolVitals dataset compares 40 tools using health score, shipping score, GitHub stars, ToolVitals score, and status so readers can separate actively maintained options from projects that may need closer review.

The ranking is ordered by ToolVitals score first, with GitHub stars used as a secondary popularity signal when scores are tied. That puts several high-shipping open-source IAM platforms at the top, while lower-scoring tools with weak or missing shipping signals fall toward the bottom even when they have name recognition or some GitHub interest.

Rankings

RankToolHealthShippingGitHub StarsScoreStatus
1Keycloak951003423194🟢 Excellent
2Zitadel1001001370894🟢 Excellent
3Stack Auth92100677994🟢 Excellent
4Authorizer90100195794🟢 Excellent
5Frontier9410033194🟢 Excellent
6Thunder9410016594🟢 Excellent
7Kotauth861005092🟢 Excellent
8Seamless Auth82100290🟢 Excellent
9BitWarden97801853989🟢 Excellent
10Pocket ID8988774189🟢 Excellent
11OPAL8988545289🟢 Excellent
12Pomerium8988478089🟢 Excellent
13AthenZ868898787🟢 Excellent
141Password8877087🟢 Excellent
15FerrisKey818858284🟢 Excellent
16Steward8188384🟢 Excellent
17Cerbos9172439482🟢 Excellent
18Weft ID78881182🟢 Excellent
19VoidAuth84100208778🟢 Good
20PearPass827243078🟢 Good
21authenticator-tauri7462169🟢 Good
22Kavachos7956069🟢 Good
23Open Authenticator76557467🟢 Good
24Ory Kratos82471362166🟢 Good
25Jans763062855🟡 Fair
26PowerAuth73306154🟡 Fair
27OpenIG46478846🟡 Fair
28ghost-auth4830240🟡 Fair
29FusionAuth71024139🔴 Needs Attention
30RootID680037🔴 Needs Attention
31Buwana640335🔴 Needs Attention
32HVT610334🔴 Needs Attention
33Tesseral520112429🔴 Needs Attention
34WAIS Core520129🔴 Needs Attention
35Authula48019026🔴 Needs Attention
36Oso460349725🔴 Needs Attention
37EAuth450225🔴 Needs Attention
38nexeres420123🔴 Needs Attention
39SSOReady360153220🔴 Needs Attention
40authman-app3006116🔴 Needs Attention

Top 3 Highlights

Keycloak ranks first with a 94 ToolVitals score, 100 shipping score, 95 health score, and 34,231 GitHub stars. It ties several tools on ToolVitals score, but its much larger GitHub star count makes it the top-ranked option under the stated tie-breaker.

Zitadel ranks second with a 94 ToolVitals score and perfect 100 scores for both health and shipping. Its 13,708 GitHub stars give it the strongest popularity signal among the tools that also reached 100 health and 100 shipping.

Stack Auth ranks third with a 94 ToolVitals score, 100 shipping score, 92 health score, and 6,779 GitHub stars. Its description positions it as an open-source Auth0 or Clerk alternative, and the data shows both strong shipping activity and meaningful GitHub traction.

Want to see the full details, pricing, and trend data for every tool in Identity & Access Management? Browse all Identity & Access Management Tools →